Pages

Monday, September 19, 2016

Stray Thoughts about Pakistan: The Formative phase, 1857-1947 by Khalid B. Sayeed

'

There is one hell of literature written about the creation of Pakistan, this field of studies started with the inception of the country and continues till today. Every person has a certain bias, and he or she sees the world through that particular bias. This phenomena is quite universal, almost everybody is under its spell. The creation of Pakistan proves to be such phenomenon, let it be people with secular tendencies or religious inclination, everybody describes this event in such a way which suits their worldview.

This book is included in CSS syllabus, that’s where I first came to hear about it. This book has been laying on my table for two years, I wasn’t be able to read it due to one reason or another. But when I started reading it, I never put it back and it was worth it
.
This book starts with the 1857 and proceeds in chronological order up to 1947 and finishes on death of Jinnah. This was published in late 60’s, so this feat saves it from the Post Zia syndrome or even Post Bhutto syndrome- In era in which text books were altered to serve a particular narrative and more than half of our population takes these books on its face value.

The most appealing part of this book is that the author interviewed a lot of people, such as Governors, Viceroys, as well as important politicians, who were directly involved in Partition either in one way or another. This particular feat gives a very crucial edge over all other books which are published later on the similar topic.

The last part of the book deals with the rise of Muslim League, from not winning any substantial seats in ’37 election to winning majority in ’46 election at least in Muslim majority provinces, and the downfall of Muslim League after the Partition. The main reasons of the downfall were that it was composed mainly of landed gentry, they had no experience in any form governance prior to partition, the whole league was transformed into a cult, Jinnah being the Messiah, and the upper as well as lower cadre of leadership was never allowed to grow as independent individuals, as a result they were wholly dependent on Jinnah. During the campaign for Pakistan Muslim League used Religious symbols, targeting the rural population of Punjab as well as NWFP, and proposed Economic opportunities, for the educated urban population who knew that in Un-divided India they had to compete more educated as well as more skilled Hindu population for jobs.

The author is on point when he describes that the aforementioned causes hampered the growth of Democracy in the early and when the euphoria of Partition was over the deep differences popped up and the incumbent leadership was not being able to solve those problems. The death of Jinnah proved to be the final nail in the coffin. To sum it up this book is a must for everyone who wants to understand the genesis of Idea of Pakistan and the problems which we find ourselves engulfed even today.

Wednesday, September 14, 2016

چی په حب د بوتراب می زړه چراغ دی

دا اویس قرنی ستر ګې لرم                       ېم دانا د لیونی سترګې لرم
ستا د مینې په مجمر په نظرمه شی       واخله ما د سپیلني سترګی لرم
ستا د در خاورو دا هسې نظر راکړ          یما مه د یمني سترګی لرم
چی می سترګی ستا په سترګوغړیدلی        ګلزاري او چمني سترګی لرم
په تنګسه کی می کړه یاد که می نظر کړه   یم چشتی د میړنی سترګی لرم
چی په حب د بوتراب می زړه چراغ دی     حسنی او حسینی سترګی لرم
په ناخوله کبره مه ږده قدمونه                  زه حمزه غرڅنی سترګی لرم

Thursday, September 1, 2016

Iqbal and Criticism

Iqbal and criticism are two antagonistic words here in Pakistan, these two are not supposed to be used in same sentence. Criticism of Iqbal is among the taboo topic of our society, no body wants to go there. 

The dilemma of whole South Asian diaspora, let it be Indian, Pakistani or Bengali, is that we believe in absolutes. Personality cults are found here in abundance. We believe, as I include my self, either in vilification or over-glorification. 

Iqbal has met the same fate, as he was declared National Poet; Pakistan owned him while India disowned him except the Urdu speaking populace. Iqbal is among-st  the best minds produced in Muslims in last Hundred years.  

Facebook