Pages

Monday, May 8, 2017

Stray thoughts about Islam and Science by Muzaffar Iqbal


Werner Heisenberg (1901-1976)-the celebrated physicist whose 1927 uncertainty principle had turned the laws of physics into statements about relative, not absolute, certainties-had recognized that as compared to the West, modern science was going to have a very different kind of impact on the rest of the world. ”One has to remember that every tool carries with it the spirit by which it has been created,” he wrote in 1958:

                               …In those parts of the world in which modern science has been
                               developed, the primary interest has been directed for a long time
                               towards physical activity, industry and engineering combined with
                               a rational analysis of the outer and inner conditions  for such activity.
                               Such people will find it rather easy to cope with the new ideas since
                               they have had time for a slow and gradual adjustment to the modern
                               scientific methods of thinking. In other parts of the world these ideas
                               would be confronted with the religious and philosophical foundations
                               of native culture. Since it is true that the results of modern physics
                               do touch such fundamental concepts as reality, space and time, the
                               confrontation may lead to entirely new developments which can’t
                               be foreseen. One characteristic feature of this meeting between
                               modern science and the older methods of thinking will be its
                               complete internationality. In this exchange of thoughts the one side,
                               the old tradition, will be different in different parts of the world, but the
                               other side will be same everywhere and therefore the results of this exchange
                               will be spread over all areas in which the discussions take place.

This is a genuine book which deals with the incumbent discourse between Islam and Science. The refreshing aspect about this book is that mostly the books dealing with Islam and Science discourse are written by two type of people, one who are modernist by tendency and have no roots in Islamic learning, while the second group comprises of people with religious tendency and they have no understanding of the modern science works. This book doesn’t suffer from any such discrepancy because the author, Muzaffar Iqbal has a PhD in Chemistry, also served as the Director of Pakistan Academy of Science in the mid 90’s, and after that his work is mainly concentrated on intellectual tradition of Islam.

In the first part of the book the author explains what the Islamic scientific tradition was, the translation movement of 8th century is discussed in detail and how the Muslims appropriated the received knowledge of Greeks and Indians. This work debunks some of the popular oriental myths of 17th century which hardly saw anything worthwhile in the Islamic scientific tradition. There exists substantial evidence which refutes the popular belief that Islamic tradition was merely a passive vehicle for the transfer of Greek science to Europe. The vertical relation between Islamic scientific tradition and the metaphysical world view of Islam and the horizontal relation between Islamic scientific tradition and the other Islamic sciences is elaborated in detail.

This book revisits popular myths such as; Islamic scientific tradition ended up in 12th century and Ghazali is solely responsible for routing the rationalists and subsequently it culminated in the collapse of Islamic golden age. A lot of new material has come to forth since 1960’s which indicates that disappearance of Islamic scientific tradition was not as simplistic as usually thought, complex process and socio-political events were involved. Quite surprisingly, Islamic scientific tradition of astronomy reached its zenith in Central Asia, Samarqand to be specific, in 14th and 15th century. The Samarqand Observatory was founded by Prince Ulugh Beg, he was himself an astronomer and mathematician. Such information clearly negates the simplistic and reductionists views that Islamic Sciences ceased to exist after 12th Century onwards and this information pushes the date of collapse of Islamic sciences into 15th century. For more details read the works of A.I. Sabra, George Saliba and Syed Nauman ul Haq.

Around quarter of the book is about the arrival of Modern Science in traditional Muslim societies-Indian sub-continent, Turkey and Middle East, and the subsequent emergence of Colonized discourse. The colonized discourse culminated in the form of Reform movements throughout Muslim world which gave rise to Catching up Syndrome- the only way to progress is adoption and transplantation of Western sciences and its technology without realizing its metaphysical and philosophical implications. This phenomena is still around in majority of Muslim lands and in many places have official patronage. In this context the roles of Reformers such as Sayyid Ahmed Khan, Syed Jamaludin Afghani, Rashid Rida and Muhammad Abduh are discussed in detail along with their fallacies.

Colonized discourse also gave birth to the new Tafsir genre, Tafsir Ilmi which means scientific exegesis. This genre of Tafsir was a breakaway from the tradition, traditionally Tafsir were mainly of two Tafsir Lughvi and Tafsir Fiqhi, and it tried to find scientific truth in the verses of Quran. This was a profane effort on part of reformers, they transgress in their claims about Quran by saying that it contains al knowledge of ancients and moderns in branches such as physics, geometry, mathematics and linguistics (1 Page 290). It is theology unsound because the main aim of Quran is guidance, not making it the web of knowledge ever known to man. This could be intriguing for anyone who wants to explore how science was in service of empire here in sub-continent and how it destroyed the indigenous scientific tradition as well as institutions, not only of Muslims but of Hindus as well.


One is shocked to know that towering figures such as Musa Al Khwarizmi and Ibn Sina in their monumental works, which ranges from mathematics to philosophy and medicine, starts with a customary invocation to God followed by salutations to the Prophet and then they proceeded directly to the subject matter. While the new practice is that Muslims are hardly interested in doing any actual science and they are left only to lace the Qur’anic verses onto any new discovery in the scientific world. In the critical analysis of the Science and its impact on the traditional societies, author heavily relies upon the Perennial thinkers such as Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Frithjof Schoun and Rene Guenon. The book is published by Suhail academy Pakistan, they are well known for publishing books on traditional Islam and perennial philosophy.

Thursday, March 16, 2017

Stray thoughts about Surkh Salam by Kamran Asdar Ali


کون بچاۓ گا پاکستان طلباء، مزور اور کسان

 روٹی،، کپڑا، اور دوا، گھر رہنےکوچھوٹا سا
مفت مجھے تعلیم دلا میں بھی مسلمان ہوں واللہ 
پاکستان کا مطلب کیا، لا الہ الا اللہ

حبیب جالب
Communism is such a taboo topic in Pakistan to talk about that even after the fall of the Soviet Union nobody is willing to discuss it. Thanks to the official patronage by the state to crush the ideology in any form throughout its history. To borrow the words of Dr Taimur Rehman,”The main reason for the weakness of the political left- read progressive left, is the Thought suppression against the left along with the Political suppression. The direct political suppression doesn’t have that much impact, eg: arresting, putting in jail etc but the thought suppression has a very strong impact and it has been practiced a lot in Pakistan.” 

The current political scenario in Pakistan is dominated by religious extremism, terrorism, and military constant intervention in politics. This book tries to challenge the current dominant narrative that history of Pakistan doesn’t constitute the aforementioned issues it consist more than that. In this process it tells us about the genesis of Communist Party Pakistan, and the role it played in the early political history of the nascent state. 
This is a well-researched academic work, because it took around 15 years for the author to muster this piece. The raison d’etre for this work, according to author, that there was hardly any authentic book about this topic-Communist Politics in Pakistan. The work covers the time between the 1947 to labor movement in Karachi 1972. Special attention has been paid to the partition and the absurdity surrounding it, and how the people reacted to it. For analyzing this response the author constantly resorts to the work of Manto. The creation of Bangladesh is discussed in detail, and the author asserts that how some portions of the history are erased from our collective memory and how some sections are constantly reiterated. 

Separate chapters are dedicated to Rawalpindi Conspiracy case, Hassan Nasir and the literary discussion between Progressive writers and their rivals. The chapter about the literary discussions really intrigued my interest. All Pakistan Progressive Writers Association was closely associated with Communist Party Pakistan, while their rival consisted of range of freethinkers, modernist poets and independent-minded intellectuals. The former group was organized while the latter was not. The PWA consisted of Sajjad Zaheer, Ahmed Nadeem Qasmi, Sibte Hassan, and Ali Sardar Jafri. On the contrary, the other group was comprised of Manto, N.M. Rashid, Hasan Askrai, M.D. Taseer and Meeraji.

One of the interesting thing that came out of this reading is that the Progressives also accuse the Manto of Obscenity and writer with no morals. Ironically the incumbent extremist elements in the society accuses him of the same thing-Obscenity and corrupting the minds of people. One thing I didn’t know before reading this book was the Labor Movement of early 1970’s. A whole section is dedicated to this issue, how it started and finished and the major characters of the movement are discussed with length. On the concluding note, the major reason for the failure or fall of Communist Party Pakistan was that it didn’t assess the ground realities correctly and blindly followed the radical line of Communist Party India, and the majority of the CPP leadership migrated from India there was hardly any indigenous leaders in the party.

Sunday, March 12, 2017

Mazdoor Kisan Party


Disaffected members of the National Awami Party formed Mazdoor Kisan Party(Major Mohammad Ishaq) in 1968. It was the first socialist/communist party in Pakistan that took the issue of working among the peasantry seriously and was successful in launching a peasant movement in NWFP in 1970.

Under this party's leadership, there were major peasant takeovers during the 1970-74 in Hashtnagar, near ancestral home of Abdul Ghaffar Khan; similar actions were also reported in Swat and the adjacent Malakand area-where there has been considerable Taliban presence in recent years.

In the late 1960's, newly invigorated Maoist groups organized peasants to fight for the eradication of feudal taxes and more just tenancy system. At the height of the movement, in the some areas of the NWFP smallholders, tenant farmers and labourers forced many large landowners to flee the villages to the cities and captured fallow land, distributing among landless peasantry.

In Hashtnagar and Malakand, a number of tenants refused to give those khans(landlords) who had left the area any share of the crop at all. The struggle turned violent, with significant loss of life and property, and thousands were arrested.

Interestingly, by 1972, after Bangladesh's independence, the NWFP had a National Awami Party (NAP) government in coalition with an Islamist party, the Jamiat-e Ulama-e Islam (JUI). At that time, Wali Khan was the leader of the party and, as mentioned, a political opponent of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Some argue that Bhutto tolerated the peasant movement as it helped in destabilizing the provincial government of his political opponents.

 Although the Maoists always denied this association, they had indeed supported Bhutto's ascendancy in Pakistani politics and had ideological disagreements with Wali Khan over his closeness to more pro-soviet communist groups. Wali Khan's nationalist and secular party was firmly against the class-based peasant struggle and it sought to divide the movement by confronting the peasantry partly on the basis of identity politics, raising the issue of Pashtun solidarity.

The landed gentry naturally applauded. The provincial government eventually subdued peasant radicalism by forming a counter-coalition of small and large landholders. As the rural economy in the NWFP had been reoriented by the green revolution towards the production of cash crops-tobacco, sugarcane and cotton- even the small and middle peasantry had prospered alongside the khans. There were some minor victories for the peasants as the right of landlords to evict tenants was rescinded. Yet, by and large, the structural imbalance between landowners and landless peasants stayed in place. A detailed history of the movement is still awaited.

Source: Surkh Salam Communist Politics and Class Activism in Pakistan 1947-72 Page 392-93

Friday, March 10, 2017

Stray Thoughts about The Sun that Rose from the Earth.


Shamsur Rahman faruqi is known as the T.S. Elliot of Urdu. Even though he is a retired civil servant, he has written several books in Urdu as well as English. His love for Meer Taqi Meer is unprecedented, he even considers him a bigger poet than Ghalib and Iqbal. He has written four volume work on Mir in which every aspect of his life is covered; book name شعر شور انگیز

This book is the translation of the original work   سوار اور دوسرے افسانے, as the translation is done by the same author so the work doesn’t lose its original touch. There are four stories in the book, three of them are related to the Ghalib, Meer and Mushafi. The story of ghalib is narrated through a Rajput, who has lost everything in the 1857 mutiny. He comes to Dehli to meet Ghalib, the ghalib of post-1857, this is a must read story for everyone who has read Dozakhnama. The Dehli and Ghalib are depicted in very graceful manner, and after reading this you can compare how two different authors approach a same issue from different perspectives.

The story of Meer starts with his love affair with an Iranian courtesan, Nurus Sadat, who comes to Dehli.  The young Meer of eccentric nature is portrayed, and the literary discussion of the day such as poetry in rekhta is not of the level of Persian and Indians can’t master Persian as the natives can, are illustrated in this section. The story of Mushafi is narrated through her wife. In this section his un-orthodox religious views, his love affairs and his friendship with Nasikh and Atish is discussed with detail. The last story deals with a person being able to time travel from the time of Ibrahim Lodhi to the 18th century, the name of this story is Timecompression.  

He uses peculiar words in his translation such as Khan of Age and Protector of the World etc. One thing that really bugged me was his over-explaining and description of people and their attire. This could be said that he is in love with 18th century India and its poets. Once asked by an interviewer that you come across a writer who lives in past. His reply was,” It’s so simplistic to describe me so. My fiction is indeed located in the cultural and literary past of Indo-Muslim way of life of 18th and 19th centuries but I don’t regard it as dead past. And I am not writing historical fiction, I am writing about poetry, love and death.”

Along with all this, he is also actively involved in reviving the art of dastangoi and he is regularly seen in the Jashn-e-Rekhta sessions.  

Thursday, February 23, 2017

Higher education and third world

Tell me about your efforts to establish an independent educational institution in Islamabad.

Higher education in Pakistan has almost totally collapsed. Higher education has collapsed or collapsing in most of the third world, including India. In India a sort of effort was made to produce technical education of high quality by the founding of the six Institutes of Indian Technology. There, no humanities, no social sciences are taught. They prepare engineers and few scientists. Otherwise, the quality of education in India has drastically declined.

The reasons for the decline of higher education are multiple. One has been the confused and in some ways very uncreative attitude of nationalist governments towards language. On the one hand, these post-colonial states want to impose linguistic orthodoxy suitable to the nationalist mythology. In Pakistan nationalist mythology Urdu, of a Persianized variety, is our official language. In India it is Hindi, of a Sanskritized variety. In Algeria it is Arabic. These are the requirements of the nationalist orthodoxy on one hand. On the other hand, these are all countries which are originally linked to the capitalist market, meaning they are interlinked to the imperial metropolis, old or new, either Britain or America, France or America. The result is that they have two set of standards, one real, the other theoretical.

In Algeria higher education is supposed to have Arabized. The reality was, the Algerian independent state remained organically tied to France and to the international market. Therefore the local language, Arabic, was devalued. So you have a situation in which you have higher education without a language. You cannot impart higher education without a consistent language policy. That contributed to the decline of education.

Second, we all inherited a colonial system of higher education. These post-colonial governments had no will or desire to introduce an alternative system of education. The rhetoric and the structure they announced was that of independence. The reality was that of higher education based on colonial premises and systems. The educational system in this new setting of post-colonial statehood became increasingly dysfunctional because it came under opposing, contradictory pressures.

Third, the function of colonial education were different. As Lord Macaulay put it,’’ We want to train in schools of higher learning Indians who would be good at mediating between the Raj and population, the large majority of Her Majesty’s subjects’’. So, this education was supposed to produce not governors or citizens or educators or administrators of an independent state. It was all meant to produce servants of the empire. This we have continued to do to this day. But that is not the expectation from the educational system. Therefore there is this increasing disjunction between expectation and reality.

Finally I should mention the World Bank, which by and large defines the preferences of post-colonial states. It discourages the investments in higher education. The World Bank’s line is that third-world countries don’t need higher education, they need more literacy. Its policies are aimed at producing a relatively more skilled pool of workers and not people who can govern themselves.



In Pakistan, Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto nationalized all the institutions. This meant bureaucrats started running universities. Police officers make really bad presidents of universities. Ditto army officers. Then Mr. Bhutto was followed by the General Muhammad Zia ul-Haq. He needed a constituency. He had none. He needed support of party. No party was willing to support him except Jamat-e-Islami, which charged a fee: Islamization of higher education institutions. During the pro-western government of Zia ul-Haq, physics professors could not be appointed if they could not name the wives of the Holy Prophet.

Khaldunia, which is the name of university I’m trying to establish, aims at reviving higher education in one third-world country. It can’t revive it on its own. It simply can set some examples and show what kind of curriculum should be the curriculum of an independent, self-governing people. It would make an effort to establish some linkages between the past and the future, some congruence between inherited tradition and contemporary knowledge.

We have colleges and universities that are graduating ignorants. So you have people with B.A and M.A degrees who cannot pass the freshman entrance test at MIT or Harvard or Amherst College. They have actually been given those tests and they can’t pass them. So the business house says,’’ Look, we have huge number of B.A’s and M.A’s here, but they’re not employable. They have no skills. They have no knowledge. They are not trained for anything. So why should be employ them?’’. The World Bank says,’’ Look how many unemployed graduates you have. So what’s the point of your having higher education?’’. It’s the same argument.

Source: Confronting Empire- Eqbal Ahmad interviews David Barsamian

Thursday, January 26, 2017

Stray Thoughts about Eqbal Ahmad: Confronting Empire

Eqbal Ahmad belonged to the rare breed of internationalists and was among the best minds produced by Pakistan along with Abdus Salam. He was at home at United States, Middle East, Africa as well as in Pakistan. It’s a shame that he is well known abroad compared to his own country. He was Political Scientist by profession, while an activist and revolutionary by zeal. During his sojourn in US he befriended comrades like Noam Chomsky, Edward Said, Howard Zinn and David Barsamian. 


This book contains set of interviews he gave to Barsamian before his death, and were published posthumously. It contains topics ranging from Kashmir, Palestine, Orientalism, to the failure of third world countries economically and politically. The introduction which is written by Edward said is a treat to read and it covers Eqbal’s life in a holistic way.

Tuesday, January 24, 2017

Khaldunia Univeristy

One of your efforts is to establish Khaldunia, an alternative university in Pakistan. How is that coming along?

Not very well. I got off to a very good start in first years, 1992 to 1993, because the press, the middle class, the government, and the industrialists all responded positively. I was almost on the brink of getting the university started when the first government of Nawaz Sharif fell. Benazir Bhutto came into office in 1993 and seems to have come in with a grudge towards me. So it seems. I had written critically of her father's performance as prime minister. I very strongly opposed the regime of Zia ul-Haq and took risks for it, but in opposing the regime I often pointed out that this tyranny was brought upon us by the blunders of Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. These are things that she must have disliked. But that isn't the real issue. The real issue is that she actually embraced a great number of supporters of Zia ul-Haq, including some of his closest friends and allies.

Another problem was that now Bhutto was in power, she felt deserved to be paid court. I was not paying court. Paying court is not something that suits my temperament. As a result, she dragged me out. The charter and the land didn't come through. She would make promises whenever editorials were written and people protested. Two or three times her government-controlled television would announce that everything had been done for Khaldunia and it was about to be opened; but actually nothing was being done. That's where it ended with three-and-a-half years of her rule. She broke my momentum. I lost a lot of credibility while I waited for her to act. She went out and Nawaz Sharif came back in.

Source: Confronting Empire- Eqbal Ahmad interviews David Barsamian
Khaldunia Univeristy was brain child of Eqbal Ahmed to establish an alternative university, in the name of Arab sociologist and historian Ibn Khaldun, for emphasis on Social sciences and Liberal Arts.      

Facebook