Pages

Thursday, February 23, 2017

Higher education and third world

Tell me about your efforts to establish an independent educational institution in Islamabad.

Higher education in Pakistan has almost totally collapsed. Higher education has collapsed or collapsing in most of the third world, including India. In India a sort of effort was made to produce technical education of high quality by the founding of the six Institutes of Indian Technology. There, no humanities, no social sciences are taught. They prepare engineers and few scientists. Otherwise, the quality of education in India has drastically declined.

The reasons for the decline of higher education are multiple. One has been the confused and in some ways very uncreative attitude of nationalist governments towards language. On the one hand, these post-colonial states want to impose linguistic orthodoxy suitable to the nationalist mythology. In Pakistan nationalist mythology Urdu, of a Persianized variety, is our official language. In India it is Hindi, of a Sanskritized variety. In Algeria it is Arabic. These are the requirements of the nationalist orthodoxy on one hand. On the other hand, these are all countries which are originally linked to the capitalist market, meaning they are interlinked to the imperial metropolis, old or new, either Britain or America, France or America. The result is that they have two set of standards, one real, the other theoretical.

In Algeria higher education is supposed to have Arabized. The reality was, the Algerian independent state remained organically tied to France and to the international market. Therefore the local language, Arabic, was devalued. So you have a situation in which you have higher education without a language. You cannot impart higher education without a consistent language policy. That contributed to the decline of education.

Second, we all inherited a colonial system of higher education. These post-colonial governments had no will or desire to introduce an alternative system of education. The rhetoric and the structure they announced was that of independence. The reality was that of higher education based on colonial premises and systems. The educational system in this new setting of post-colonial statehood became increasingly dysfunctional because it came under opposing, contradictory pressures.

Third, the function of colonial education were different. As Lord Macaulay put it,’’ We want to train in schools of higher learning Indians who would be good at mediating between the Raj and population, the large majority of Her Majesty’s subjects’’. So, this education was supposed to produce not governors or citizens or educators or administrators of an independent state. It was all meant to produce servants of the empire. This we have continued to do to this day. But that is not the expectation from the educational system. Therefore there is this increasing disjunction between expectation and reality.

Finally I should mention the World Bank, which by and large defines the preferences of post-colonial states. It discourages the investments in higher education. The World Bank’s line is that third-world countries don’t need higher education, they need more literacy. Its policies are aimed at producing a relatively more skilled pool of workers and not people who can govern themselves.



In Pakistan, Prime Minister Zulfikar Ali Bhutto nationalized all the institutions. This meant bureaucrats started running universities. Police officers make really bad presidents of universities. Ditto army officers. Then Mr. Bhutto was followed by the General Muhammad Zia ul-Haq. He needed a constituency. He had none. He needed support of party. No party was willing to support him except Jamat-e-Islami, which charged a fee: Islamization of higher education institutions. During the pro-western government of Zia ul-Haq, physics professors could not be appointed if they could not name the wives of the Holy Prophet.

Khaldunia, which is the name of university I’m trying to establish, aims at reviving higher education in one third-world country. It can’t revive it on its own. It simply can set some examples and show what kind of curriculum should be the curriculum of an independent, self-governing people. It would make an effort to establish some linkages between the past and the future, some congruence between inherited tradition and contemporary knowledge.

We have colleges and universities that are graduating ignorants. So you have people with B.A and M.A degrees who cannot pass the freshman entrance test at MIT or Harvard or Amherst College. They have actually been given those tests and they can’t pass them. So the business house says,’’ Look, we have huge number of B.A’s and M.A’s here, but they’re not employable. They have no skills. They have no knowledge. They are not trained for anything. So why should be employ them?’’. The World Bank says,’’ Look how many unemployed graduates you have. So what’s the point of your having higher education?’’. It’s the same argument.

Source: Confronting Empire- Eqbal Ahmad interviews David Barsamian

Facebook