Pages

Monday, May 8, 2017

Stray thoughts about Islam and Science by Muzaffar Iqbal


Werner Heisenberg (1901-1976)-the celebrated physicist whose 1927 uncertainty principle had turned the laws of physics into statements about relative, not absolute, certainties-had recognized that as compared to the West, modern science was going to have a very different kind of impact on the rest of the world. ”One has to remember that every tool carries with it the spirit by which it has been created,” he wrote in 1958:

                               …In those parts of the world in which modern science has been
                               developed, the primary interest has been directed for a long time
                               towards physical activity, industry and engineering combined with
                               a rational analysis of the outer and inner conditions  for such activity.
                               Such people will find it rather easy to cope with the new ideas since
                               they have had time for a slow and gradual adjustment to the modern
                               scientific methods of thinking. In other parts of the world these ideas
                               would be confronted with the religious and philosophical foundations
                               of native culture. Since it is true that the results of modern physics
                               do touch such fundamental concepts as reality, space and time, the
                               confrontation may lead to entirely new developments which can’t
                               be foreseen. One characteristic feature of this meeting between
                               modern science and the older methods of thinking will be its
                               complete internationality. In this exchange of thoughts the one side,
                               the old tradition, will be different in different parts of the world, but the
                               other side will be same everywhere and therefore the results of this exchange
                               will be spread over all areas in which the discussions take place.

This is a genuine book which deals with the incumbent discourse between Islam and Science. The refreshing aspect about this book is that mostly the books dealing with Islam and Science discourse are written by two type of people, one who are modernist by tendency and have no roots in Islamic learning, while the second group comprises of people with religious tendency and they have no understanding of the modern science works. This book doesn’t suffer from any such discrepancy because the author, Muzaffar Iqbal has a PhD in Chemistry, also served as the Director of Pakistan Academy of Science in the mid 90’s, and after that his work is mainly concentrated on intellectual tradition of Islam.

In the first part of the book the author explains what the Islamic scientific tradition was, the translation movement of 8th century is discussed in detail and how the Muslims appropriated the received knowledge of Greeks and Indians. This work debunks some of the popular oriental myths of 17th century which hardly saw anything worthwhile in the Islamic scientific tradition. There exists substantial evidence which refutes the popular belief that Islamic tradition was merely a passive vehicle for the transfer of Greek science to Europe. The vertical relation between Islamic scientific tradition and the metaphysical world view of Islam and the horizontal relation between Islamic scientific tradition and the other Islamic sciences is elaborated in detail.

This book revisits popular myths such as; Islamic scientific tradition ended up in 12th century and Ghazali is solely responsible for routing the rationalists and subsequently it culminated in the collapse of Islamic golden age. A lot of new material has come to forth since 1960’s which indicates that disappearance of Islamic scientific tradition was not as simplistic as usually thought, complex process and socio-political events were involved. Quite surprisingly, Islamic scientific tradition of astronomy reached its zenith in Central Asia, Samarqand to be specific, in 14th and 15th century. The Samarqand Observatory was founded by Prince Ulugh Beg, he was himself an astronomer and mathematician. Such information clearly negates the simplistic and reductionists views that Islamic Sciences ceased to exist after 12th Century onwards and this information pushes the date of collapse of Islamic sciences into 15th century. For more details read the works of A.I. Sabra, George Saliba and Syed Nauman ul Haq.

Around quarter of the book is about the arrival of Modern Science in traditional Muslim societies-Indian sub-continent, Turkey and Middle East, and the subsequent emergence of Colonized discourse. The colonized discourse culminated in the form of Reform movements throughout Muslim world which gave rise to Catching up Syndrome- the only way to progress is adoption and transplantation of Western sciences and its technology without realizing its metaphysical and philosophical implications. This phenomena is still around in majority of Muslim lands and in many places have official patronage. In this context the roles of Reformers such as Sayyid Ahmed Khan, Syed Jamaludin Afghani, Rashid Rida and Muhammad Abduh are discussed in detail along with their fallacies.

Colonized discourse also gave birth to the new Tafsir genre, Tafsir Ilmi which means scientific exegesis. This genre of Tafsir was a breakaway from the tradition, traditionally Tafsir were mainly of two Tafsir Lughvi and Tafsir Fiqhi, and it tried to find scientific truth in the verses of Quran. This was a profane effort on part of reformers, they transgress in their claims about Quran by saying that it contains al knowledge of ancients and moderns in branches such as physics, geometry, mathematics and linguistics (1 Page 290). It is theology unsound because the main aim of Quran is guidance, not making it the web of knowledge ever known to man. This could be intriguing for anyone who wants to explore how science was in service of empire here in sub-continent and how it destroyed the indigenous scientific tradition as well as institutions, not only of Muslims but of Hindus as well.


One is shocked to know that towering figures such as Musa Al Khwarizmi and Ibn Sina in their monumental works, which ranges from mathematics to philosophy and medicine, starts with a customary invocation to God followed by salutations to the Prophet and then they proceeded directly to the subject matter. While the new practice is that Muslims are hardly interested in doing any actual science and they are left only to lace the Qur’anic verses onto any new discovery in the scientific world. In the critical analysis of the Science and its impact on the traditional societies, author heavily relies upon the Perennial thinkers such as Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Frithjof Schoun and Rene Guenon. The book is published by Suhail academy Pakistan, they are well known for publishing books on traditional Islam and perennial philosophy.

Facebook